Remedy and reaction the peculiar american struggle over health care reform, paul starr, yale university press. The peculiar american struggle over health care reform. This novel is an eyeopener and it has great wisdom to share to students and people of. Law and the fog of health care, saint louis university journal of health law and policy 6 20, 2228. His 1984 book the social transformation of american medicine won the pulitzer prize for nonfiction and the bancroft prize in american history. The second half of the social transformation of american medicine focuses on the transformation of medicine into an industry and the growing role of corporations and the state in the medical system. Starr explores how the united states became so stubbornly different in health care and why weve been fighting over it for a century. A multiple prizewinning author of several books and the cofounder and coeditor of the american prospect, starr lives in princeton, new jersey. Paul starrs compact but thorough remedy and reaction is an unofficial companion volume to his pulitzer prizewinning 1982 book, the social transformation of american medicine. A senior adviser on health policy in the clinton white. In remedy and reaction, professor paul starr puts the patient protection and affordable care act ppaca and earlier efforts to achieve universal health coverage into historical and political context. Paul starr, 61, a pulitzer prizewinning author, american prospect magazine cofounder and princeton sociology professor, is firmly rooted in a past infused with the lessons from his pediatrician.
Starr limits medicine to mean personal medical services and public health. In the final chapters of book one, starr examines dispensaries and their evolvement over time, the three phases of public health and the rise of new specialty clinics, and the resistance to the corporatization of medicine by doctors. Paul starr reality checks medicare for all managed. Starr provides a roadmap to the evolution of the healthcare debate, a profile of participants and an explanation and interpretation of ideological jargon in a. Let us be the ones to say we are not satisfied that your place of birth determines your right for life. The book is deeply informative, well written, and clearly conveys the role of physicians in ensuring that the health care system in this country fit their needs at least until the 1970s or so. Starr begins with a discussion on how social insurance came about, how it evolved into a political issue, and why america lagged behind other countries with regards to. His book, in consequence, is a history of medical care, not a history of health and disease in a political system that determines to a considerable degree who will suffer and who will be spared. Another book by professor starr, the logic of healthcare reform 1992,reissued in a revised and expanded edition in 1994 laid out the case for a system of universal health insurance and managed competition. Paul starr, the princeton heathcare reform expert and historian who was a senior healthcare policy adviser during the formulation of the failed clinton administration healthcare plan, poured cold water on the financial and political prospects of medicare for all today at a symposium at the university of pennsylvania law school. How neoliberal policy shaped the internetand what to do about it now, the american prospect fall 2019, 4854. Paul starr is a professor of sociology and public affairs at princeton university.
However, if youre only going to read one book on the aca and health reform, it should be paul starrs remedy and reaction. Paul starr center for the study of democratic politics. Buy a cheap copy of the social transformation of american. Paul starr has 43 books on goodreads with 44007 ratings.
Also, check out his ted talk, american struggle over health care reform. Aaron, coauthor of using taxes to reform health care. Paul starr, professor of sociology and public affairs at princeton and author of the pulitzer prizewinning book the social transformation of american medicine, has now provided us with a thorough analysis of the history of health care reform in america. Once again, starrs brilliant and lucid historical sociology illuminates the present as well as the past. Paul starr, a professor of sociology and public affairs at princeton university, is an expert on american health care policy and its history. Remedy and reaction the peculiar american struggle over. The new masters of the universe, foreign affairs novemberdecember 2019. Paul starr has written a fascinating chronicle of americas centurylong journey to health reform that is, at once, erudite history, vivid journalism, and authoritative guide to a debate that will continue for decades.
This book is a history of how and why the united states became so stubbornly different in health care, presented by an expert with unsurpassed knowledge of the issues. Books by paul starr author of the social transformation. Many of the early hmos were subsequently bought by forprofit insurers, said starr, who authored a pulitzer prizewinning book about the history of american health care. He also mentions of not being worried of the acas downfalls now, but what it can do for the future. Tracing health care reform from its beginnings to its current uncertain prospects, paul starr argues that the united states ensnared itself in a trap through policies that satisfied enough of the public and so enriched the health care industry as to make the system difficult to change. Over my vacation i read a bit on the history of health care in the united states. S ociologist paul starr, the stuart professor of communications and public affairs, has participated in the healthcare reform debate for decades, as an academic his 1984 book, won the pulitzer prize and the bancroft prize and as an adviser in the clinton white house in 1993.
Tracing healthcare reform from its beginnings to its current uncertain prospects, paul starr argues that the united states ensnared itself in a trap through policies that satisfied enough of the public and so enriched the healthcare industry as. The landmark book won starr a pulitzer two years later. Tracing healthcare reform from its beginnings to its current uncertain prospects, paul starr argues that the united states ensnared itself in a trap through policies that. Professor of sociology and public affairs, and stuart professor of communications and public affairs, princeton university photo. During 1993 he served as a senior advisor at the white house in the formulation of the clinton health plan. Notes on the social history of american medicine, self. If your interested in this book check out starrs book remedy and reaction about the health policy of the affordable care act and the context in which it was passed and strategies used to pass the legislation. I wish i knew as much about anything as starr knows about the history of health care in america. Winner of the 1983 pulitzer prize and the bancroft prize in american history, this is a landmark history of how the entire american health care system of doctors. The social transformation of american medicine wikipedia. A senior advisor on health policy in the clinton white house, he writes frequently on.
A short book by professor starr, the logic of healthcare reform 1992, reissued in a revised and expanded edition in 1994 laid out the case for a system of universal health insurance and managed competition. The goals of this book is to inform readers about all kinds of different. The peculiar american struggle over health care reform by. In the second half of the book, starr focuses on the ways in which forprofit corporations, such as insurance companies and hospitals, challenged the medical authority of doctors in the later decades of the 20th century, producing the healthcare systemmuch criticized yet much enviedthat the u. The transformation of medicine, health care, insurance, and. Unless youre a true health policy nerd, youve probably never heard of a book written by renowned princeton sociology professor paul starr entitled the social transformation of american medicine the book is the definitive history of the american health care system and examines how the roles of doctors, hospitals, health plans and government programs have. He also has written extensively about health care and other topics as a journalist, particularly at. Sean wilentz, author of the rise of american democracy. Following his 1984 pulitzer prizewinning book, the social transformation of american medicine, paul starr has written a new indepth account of the developing health care reforms since, with an insiders perspective from his days as senior advisor to president clinton on health care policy. The passage of the affordable care act has seen a number of books published about how the law was designed and successfully enacted, written by a wide range of authors from tom daschle to a team of washington post reporters.
The social transformation of american medicine is a book written by paul starr and published by basic books in 1982. By vicente navarro professor of health and public policy the johns hopkins university 102407. The united states spends a disproportionate amount on health careabout 17. The social transformation of american medicine, by paul starr, was first published in 1982.
Paul starr mentions a great deal of the health care reforms ideals of securing health care for americans and how health care has been vastly different. Tedx talk on supreme court and the struggle over health care reform. Starr points out that in any given year, the most costly 5 percent of people account for more than 50 percent of healthcare costs, and the top 10 percent of people. The mandate miscalculation, the new republic december 29, 2011, 11. Paul starrs book about the social transformation of. In his article the hillarycare mythology the american prospect, october 2007, pp. A landmark history of how the entire american health care system of doctors, hospitals, health. This piece looked at paul starrs pulitzer prizewinning book about the social transformation of american medicine and explored how the issues he discusses can shed light on the current vituperative health care reform debate. In the first section, he details the rise of professional authority among physicians in the. Reform and counterreform in american health care, journal of health politics, policy, and law.
Entrenchment is paul starrs most ambitious book to date, analyzing how political, social, and economic changes consolidate and endure. Struggle over health care reform by paul starr yale university press, 335 pp. The social transformation of american medicine by paul starr. Paul starr is professor of sociology and public affairs, princeton university, and cofounder and coeditor of the american prospect.
Remedy and reaction accomplishes several tasks in its brisk 300 pages. Starr says a seminal moment in health care as a national issue took shape when he became an adviser to harris wofford, who won the 1991. It won the 1984 pulitzer prize for general nonfiction as well as the bancroft prize capers jones wrote, paul starrs book detailed the attempts of the american medical association to improve academic training of physicians, establish a canon of professional. Paul starr is a professor of sociology and public affairs at princeton university and holds the stuart chair in communications and public affairs at the woodrow wilson school of public affairs.
Aaron, coauthor of using taxes to reform health care henry aaron 20110602. Starrs compendium is a valuable reference that will provide a historical and worldview as we discuss organized medicine, national health care, physician, hospital, insurance, nursing and allied health issues in our journal over the next six months. His 2011 book, remedy and reaction, is a history of the politics of health care reform, and he was the senior adviser to president clinton and his managed competition health care reform plan in 1993 starrs the social transformation. The author, a professor of sociology and public affairs at princeton, gives a fascinating, relevant account in two chunks. The peculiar american struggle over health care reform by paul starr, starr begins by familiarizing how health care began, how it has changed throughout the years, and how health care is today.
1068 1245 1579 1330 1327 1248 1431 259 911 1216 449 98 330 556 437 994 1592 483 1176 1310 571 698 1393 726 518 1362 778 519 209 1086 168 474